Greetings

Welcome to The Forecite Blog™ -- Criminal Jury Instructions Prepared by Tom Lundy. This is a blog about criminal jury instructions from the defense perspective. The goal of the blog is to highlight recent state and federal cases which suggest issues and strategies relevant to jury instruction practice. The blog will also include selected sample instructions from recent cases.

Best Regards,
Thomas F. Lundy
Editor in Chief
Forecite National
Forecite California

Disclaimer: Legal opinions on The Forecite Blog™ are provided for informational purposes only and should not be relied on as a substitute for legal advice from a licensed lawyer. The Forecite Blog™ does not warrant that the information is complete or accurate.

Citation Caveat: Many of the opinions cited in this blog are not yet final or are unpublished. Therefore you should not cite or rely on any judicial decision referenced in The Forecite Blog™ without independently verifying the opinion's status as citable precedent. The rules of the applicable jurisdiction should be consulted before citing to an unpublished opinion or relying on it as precedent.

Copyright © 2010, 2011, 2012 Thomas F. Lundy. All Rights Reserved. E-mail tlundy@juryinstruction.com for permissions.

Wednesday, August 4, 2010

Sample Instruction: Uncharged Offenses Or Bad Acts Must Be Proved Beyond A Reasonable Doubt

You are instructed that if there is any evidence before you of the defendant having committed any other offenses or bad acts, other than the offense alleged against him in the indictment in this case, you cannot consider such evidence for any other purpose unless you first find and believe beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant committed such other offenses or bad acts, if any, and even then, you may only consider such evidence to aid you in determining, if it does aid you, the defendant's intent, knowledge, plan, scheme, if any, to commit the offense alleged against him in the indictment in this case.

Source: Approved in Howard v. State, (Tex. App. Dallas, No. 05-08-01119-CR, Feb. 26, 2010) [NOTICE: This opinion is UNPUBLISHED.] [citing Chaddock v. State, 203 S.W.3d 916, 924 (Tex. App.--Dallas 2006, no pet.).]

For subscription based briefing and sample instructions on this and related issues see:

Forecite National™

25.19 - Uncharged Acts: Nonpropensity
25.20 - Uncharged Acts To Prove Propensity (FRE 413-415)
26.5 - Uncharged Acts To Prove Issues Other Than Propensity
65.1.1 - Natural And Probable Consequence: Prejudicial Impact Of The Failure To Instruct On Elements Of Uncharged Target Offense
The Shellow Instructions
Limited Purpose Evidence: Uncharged Offenses And Acts
Forecite California™
F 2.50 - Other Crimes, Uncharged Offenses
F 2.50.1 - Other Crimes Evidence